Decline Medicare Part A and Lose Your Social Security Benefits

How Social Security Binds You to Medicare

Part A and SSDI
Refusing Medicare Part A could mean losing your disability benefits. Huntstock/Brand X Pictures/Getty Images

Medicare is not only for those older than 65 years of age. It is a benefit offered to those who have disabilities, assuming they meet certain disability criteria. The problem is you may not want Medicare if you could get cheaper health insurance somewhere else.

Don't act on that impulse!

What Disabilities Qualify You for Medicare?

If you fall into one of the following disability categories, you may be eligible for Medicare even if you are younger than 65 years old.

Paying Into the System

People who qualify for Medicare have paid for that benefit. The number of years you or your spouse pay the federal government in payroll taxes determines not only your eligibility for the health-care program but how much you will pay. These tax dollars are intended to safeguard entitlement benefits for you when you need them in the future.

The Cost of Medicare

While Medicare offers health care to the disabled, it is not free. You have to pay premiums for the different parts.

  • Premiums must be paid for Part A if someone has not worked at least 40 quarters (10 years) of taxed employment.
  • Everyone pays premiums for Part B, an amount determined by your income.
  • If you want prescription drug coverage, you will pay premiums for Part D as well.

In lieu of these options, you may pick a Medicare Advantage plan. Medicare Advantage plans include everything that Part A and Part B cover and may include Part D coverage if you choose.

Like the other parts of Medicare, these plans will cost you a monthly premium.

Other health plan costs include deductibles, coinsurance, and copayments too.

When Other Insurance Plans Cost Less than Medicare

You may find that other insurance options are less expensive for you than Medicare.

Obamacare plans may sound appealing but be careful. You are not allowed to have any part of Medicare and an Obamacare plan at the same time. Another option would be to sign up for health coverage through your spouse's health plan. Better yet, you may be eligible for health care based on your military experience, whether through the VA or TRICARE.

In these cases, you may be tempted to decline Medicare in favor of another insurance. After all, no one wants to pay two premiums if they don't have to. You need to understand that declining Medicare can have serious repercussions.

It is unclear at this time how an Obamacare repeal will affect insurance access. This will depend on what kind of replacement plan the Trump administration puts forward.

Declining Part A Coverage

If you decline Part A coverage, you could lose your Social Security benefits. This could include your retirement benefits or even benefits from SSDI. Not only will you lose the future income from Social Security but you will have to pay back any Social Security benefits you received up to the time you declined Part A.

A ruling by a U.S. District Court in 2001 addressed this very issue. Three federal employees sued the government because they wanted to discontinue Part A in favor of coverage under the Federal Employees Health Benefit (FEHB) program. At the same time, they wanted to keep their Social Security benefits.

The 1965 law that created both Social Security and Medicare provided the answer. Judge Collyer stated that "requiring a mechanism for Plaintiffs and others in their situation to 'dis-enroll' would be contrary to congressional intent, which was to provide 'mandatory' benefits under Medicare Part A for those receiving Social Security Retirement benefits." Translated, the ruling states people cannot disenroll from Medicare Part A without also losing their Social Security benefits.

Declining Part B Coverage

If you decline Part B coverage, you may be faced with late penalties when you sign up at a later time. Unlike with Part A, this will not cause you to lose your Social Security benefits. This is because you do not pay taxes for Medicare Part B.

What You Should Do

Most people get Part A for free. If this is the case, it is usually in your best interest to enroll and continue Medicare coverage to secure your Social Security benefits. Be very careful about waiving your Part A coverage. It could cost you!

Sources:

Civil Action No. 08-1715 (RMC) - Memorandum Opinion. United States District Court for the District of Columbia website. https://ecf.dcd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/show_public_doc?2008cv1715-54. Published March 16, 2001.

Continue Reading