10 Surprising Reasons Why Kids Misbehave

The Real Reasons that Kids Don't Follow the Rules

There are many reasons why kids misbehave on purpose.
Frank Herholdt / The Image Bank / Getty Images

Kids use their behavior to show how they’re feeling and what they’re thinking. Often, they’re communicating something through their behavior that they aren’t necessarily able to verbalize.

When determining what discipline strategy to use, consider the possible underlying cause for the behavior problem.

1. They Want Attention

When parents talk on the phone, visiting with friends or family, or otherwise occupied, kids feel left out.

And throwing a tantrum, whining, or hitting a sibling is a great way to attract attention.

Even if it’s negative attention, kids still crave it. Ignoring negative behavior and praising positive behavior is one of the best ways to deal with attention-seeking behaviors.

2. They're Copying Others

Kids learn how to behave by watching others. Whether they see a peer at school misbehave or they’re copying something they’ve seen on TV, kids will repeat it.

Limit your kids' exposure to aggressive behavior on TV, in video games, and in real life. Role model healthy behavior to teach your child the appropriate way to behave in various situations.

3. They're Testing Limits

When you’ve established rules and told kids what they’re not allowed to do, they often want to see if you’re serious. They test limits just to find out what the consequences will be when they break the rules.

Set clear limits and offer consequences consistently.

If kids think there’s a small chance they may be able to get away with something, they’re often tempted to try it. If you show them that they'll receive a negative consequence each time they break a rule, they’ll start to become more compliant.

4. They Lack Skills

Sometimes behavior problems stem from a lack of skills.

A child who lacks social skills may hit another child because he wants to play with a toy. A child who lacks problem-solving skills may not clean his room because he isn’t sure what to do when his toys don’t fit in the toy box.

When your child misbehaves, instead of just giving him a consequence, teach him what to do instead. Show him alternatives to misbehavior so he can learn from his mistakes.

5. They Want Independence

As preschoolers learn to do more things on their own, they often want to show off their new skills. Tweens also are known for their attempts to be independent. They may become more argumentative and may behave disrespectfully at times.

Teens may become rebellious in an attempt to show adults that they can think for themselves. They may break the rules on purpose and may try to show adults that they can’t be forced to do things they don’t want to do.

Give your child appropriate choices. Ask your preschooler, "Do you want water or ice water to drink?" Tell your teenager, "It's up to you to decide when you do your chores. And as soon as your chores are done, you can use your electronics." Giving age-appropriate freedom will meet your child's need to be independent. 

6. They Can’t Control Their Emotions

Sometimes kids have no idea what to do about their feelings.

They may become easily overwhelmed when they feel angry, and as a result, they may become aggressive. They may even act out when they feel excited, stressed, or bored.

Kids need to learn healthy ways to deal with feelings such as sadness, disappointment, frustration, and anxiety. Teach kids about feelings and show them healthy ways to manage their emotions to prevent them from misbehaving.

When kids have better control over their emotions, they can use healthy coping skills to deal with their feelings. Instead of misbehaving to express their emotions, a child may learn to take a time-out to calm down.

7. They Have Unmet Needs

When a child feels hungry, tired, or ill, misbehavior often ensues. Most toddlers and preschoolers aren’t good at communicating what they need.

As a result, they often use their behavior to show that they have unmet needs. Parents can help prevent behavior problems by looking for unmet needs.

For example, take a toddler shopping after he’s had a nap and when you’ve got snacks on hand. Ask your child how he’s feeling and look for cues that he may have some unmet needs.

8. They Want Power and Control

Power and control often contribute to misbehavior. Sometimes defiant and argumentative behavior results when a child attempts to regain some control.

When behavior problems result from a child’s attempt to have some control over a situation, a power struggle may ensue. One way to avoid a power struggle is to offer a child two choices. For example, ask “Would you rather clean your room now or after this TV show is over?”

By offering two choices, you can give kids some control over the situation. This can reduce a lot of arguments and can get increase the likelihood that a child will comply with instructions.

9. Misbehavior Is Effective

One of the simplest reasons children misbehave is because it is effective. If breaking the rules gets them what they want, they’ll quickly learn that misbehavior works.

For example, a child who whines until his mother gives in will learn that whining is a great way to get whatever he wants. Or a child who throws a temper tantrum in the middle of the store, and his father agrees to buy him a toy to get him to stop screaming, learns that temper tantrums are effective.

Make sure that your child's misbehavior isn't serving him well. While giving in or backing down may make your life easier in the moment, you'll ultimately be training your child to break the rules.

10. Underlying Mental Health Issues

Sometimes children have underlying mental health issues that contribute to behavior problems. Kids with ADHD, for example, struggle to follow directions and behave impulsively.

Underlying anxiety or depression can also contribute to behavior problems. An anxious child may avoid going to classes that make him feel nervous. A depressed child may be irritable and lack the motivation to complete his chores or his school work.

If you suspect your child may have any underlying mental health issue or developmental disorder, talk to your child’s pediatrician. An evaluation by a trained mental health professional may be necessary to determine if there are any underlying emotional issues contributing to behavior problems.

Sources

HealthyChildren.org: Normal Child Behavior

Weitzman C, Wegner L. Promoting Optimal Development: Screening for Behavioral and Emotional ProblemsPediatrics. 2015;135(5):946-946. ​

Continue Reading