Weight Training With Osteoarthritis

Does It Help or Hurt?

Seniors weight training
PeopleImages/Getty Images

Weight training, which involves using weights while you exercise, can help a person strengthen their muscles, including those that surround the joints. Strong muscles help to stabilize the joints. While that makes sense and sounds like something we all should be doing, is weight training appropriate for people with osteoarthritis?

Before we move forward to answer that question, let's sort out terminology that often is used interchangeably.

Strength training, weight training, and resistance exercise—are they one and the same? In fact, strength training is the broader term which encompasses the other two. Strength training refers to any exercise that uses some form of resistance to strengthen muscle. The resistance forces skeletal muscles to contract. The resistance can be created by using weight machines, hand-held weights, resistance bands (e.g., Therabands), and resistance balls. Resistance can be created by using your own body, too.

People with osteoarthritis, as well as the other types of arthritis, have long been encouraged to keep moving and to participate in regular physical activity or exercise. Primarily, low-impact exercise and range-of-motion exercise is emphasized for people with arthritis. That's exactly the source of confusion. If weight resistance is added to an exercise regimen, does it hurt more than help someone with osteoarthritis?

According to Dr. Mehmet Oz:

You can lift weights and do bodybuilding if you have one or more joints with osteoarthritis, but you'll need to be very careful. If any part of your workout causes pain in the affected joints, stop. You may need to stop doing some exercises or do them with lighter weights or fewer repetitions. Staying active and physically fit helps manage osteoarthritis, but continuing to work out through pain isn't a good idea. You can make your osteoarthritis worse by injuring the joint.

What Studies Say About Weight Training and Osteoarthritis

A meta-analysis of eight randomized controlled trials for progressive resistance strength training by older people with osteoarthritis was performed and published in Clinics in Geriatric Medicine. Focusing on older people is significant because they are commonly affected by muscle weakness, as well as osteoarthritis.

Peak muscle strength normally occurs in your mid-20s and that is maintained into your 60s. But, strength declines and by the time you are 80 years old, your strength is about half that of a normal young adult. The loss of muscle mass and strength that occurs with age is called sarcopenia. Muscle weakness is also common with osteoarthritis, especially of the knee extensors. Muscle weakness occurring with osteoarthritis is linked to an increased increased risk of functional limitations and disability. Muscle strength, especially knee extensor strength, has been found to be protective against developing functional limitations in those with osteoarthritis.

According to the meta-analysis, it was also determined that in older adults, even those of very advanced age, muscle strength can be improved with a progressive overload strength training program.

Strength training can improve gait speed, ability to stand up from a chair, and other daily activities. The effect of strength training on function and disability was apparent, as was pain reduction. When the effect of strength training on function was compared between older people with osteoarthritis and those who did not have the disease, a small functional effect in those without osteoarthritis was found versus a moderate functional effect in those with osteoarthritis.

An Appropriate Level of Weight Training for People With Osteoarthritis

It must be remembered that strength training, if overdone, can stress joints affected by osteoarthritis, possibly increasing pain and decreasing function.

There should be discussion about the most appropriate level of strength training, especially weight training, for people with osteoarthritis. Before starting a weight training program, if you have osteoarthritis, you should:

  • Discuss weight training with your doctor to become more aware of potential benefits and risks.
  • Consult with a physical therapist about weight training with osteoarthritis. Get a physical therapy referral from your doctor. The therapist can then evaluate you and make recommendations which are customized for you.
  • Seek out a supervised weight training program at a gym with a personal trainer or at a physical therapy clinic with a therapist. A supervised setting is more optimal compared to a home-based program, especially at first. There seems to be greater commitment and adherence to a supervised setting.
  • Be mindful of the potential effect of your medications. If you take analgesic medication, for example, it may mask your pain and you may unknowingly push beyond your limits, risking injury or causing your osteoarthritis symptoms to worsen.

As you are preparing to engage in a weight training program, you should:

  • Warm up as you begin! Do light stretching exercises as well.
  • Utilize light weights, especially at first, as you become familiar with proper technique. Increase the weight in small increments when you feel that the current level has become too easy.
  • Maintain proper body alignment during weight training—yet another reason that supports having supervision. Proper alignment helps to lessen strain on joints.
  • Work opposing muscle groups to achieve balance. When there is balance between muscle groups, joint stability is enhanced.
  • Consider wearing orthopedic braces or supports on affected joints. However, weightlifting belts are not recommended for people with osteoarthritis.
  • Consider using a hot pack on affected joints and muscles before starting your routine to reduce pain and increase circulation. Cold packs may be used following exercise to decrease inflammation.
  • Wear appropriate, comfortable footwear. If you wear an orthotic, try to keep it in place to ensure the best support and alignment.
  • Alternate between weightbearing and non-weightbearing exercise, to lessen stress and strain on your joints.
  • Cool down after your routine.

A Word From Verywell

There is no evidence to suggest that older adults with osteoarthritis who exercise face a greater risk of adverse events (e.g., worsening pain) or that they are unable to effectively strengthen their muscles compared to younger adults. In fact, some level of exercise is possible no matter one's age or the severity of osteoarthritis. Reasonably, we can assume that increased age or increased severity of osteoarthritis may necessitate an adjustment of using less weight in weight training. But, it can still be done, at some level which is deemed appropriate.

Be smart. If you experience any of the following symptoms, stop weight training or any form of exercise and notify your therapist, trainer, and doctor: increased pain or swelling in muscles or joints; popping, locking, or buckling of an affected joint; pain in muscles or joints that was not previously present; abdominal pain; chest pain; groin pain; shortness of breath.

Sources: 

Kalunian KC. Patient Guidelines for Weight-Resistance Training in Osteoarthritis. UpToDate. Updated August 17, 2016.

Latham N and Liu C. Strength Training in Older Adults: The Benefits for Osteoarthritis. Clinics in Geriatric Medicine. August 2010.

Oz, M. Can Weight Lifting or Bodybuilding Make My Osteoarthritis Worse? Sharecare.com.

Continue Reading